Myth: the church hid the “original” gospels that differ from the Bible. Fact: these gospels were never hidden. Second-century church writers such as Irenaeus actually named and discussed them openly.
The main issue is when they were written. Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John were written in the first century, within the lifetime of the eyewitnesses. Most of the other gospels, such as the Gospel of Judas and the Gospel of Philip, come from the 2nd to 3rd centuries, one to two centuries after Jesus.
Their content is also far removed from the first-century Jewish world in which Jesus lived, and heavily influenced by Gnostic teaching, which held that the material world is evil. The church rejected them not out of fear, but because they couldn’t be traced back to the apostles.
Full explanation & Bible references
1. Discussed openly from early on
Irenaeus (around 180) mentions a “Gospel of Judas” used by a Gnostic group. Manuscripts such as the Gospel of Thomas were found at Nag Hammadi, Egypt, in 1945, and can now be read by anyone in translation.
2. Comparing their ages
- The canonical Gospels: around AD 65–95.
- The Gospel of Thomas: many scholars place it in the mid-2nd century, though some of its sayings are debated.
- The Gospel of Judas: around AD 150–180.
- The Gospel of Mary and the Gospel of Philip: 2nd–3rd century.
3. The criteria the church used
The early church judged writings by their connection to the apostles, their agreement with the teaching it had received, and their wide use in the churches. See What is the biblical canon?, What is the Apocrypha?, and What is in the Gospel of Barnabas?
Next step
See the other questions in Stage 5, or read about other myths in the Christian Facts vs Myths category.
References
- Irenaeus, Against Heresies 1.31.1.
- Simon Gathercole, The Gospel of Thomas: Introduction and Commentary (2014).
- Craig A. Evans, Fabricating Jesus (2006).
- Darrell L. Bock, The Missing Gospels (2006).
Comments
Post a Comment