We all rely on reason to judge what is true, including when we judge whether God exists. But there is a question that is rarely asked: if there is no God, why should we believe our reason can be trusted?
If the human mind is only the product of a purposeless natural process, then our beliefs were shaped because they were useful for survival, not because they are true. C.S. Lewis pointed out the problem: that view saws off the branch it is sitting on. If reason is only the product of blind cause and effect, then the arguments for atheism can’t be trusted either.
On the other hand, if humans were created by a rational God, it makes sense that our minds can understand the world, and that nature can be studied by science. The Christian faith doesn’t ask us to switch off our minds; it actually explains why reason is worth using.
Full explanation & Bible references
1. The hidden question
Every argument, including arguments against God, assumes that reason can find truth. That is not an absolute proof of God, but it is a clue: in a worldview without God, trust in reason becomes hard to explain.
2. Lewis’s argument
In Miracles (chapter 3), Lewis argues that if thought is entirely the product of irrational natural processes, we have no reason to believe our thoughts are true. Even Charles Darwin once wrote in a letter (1881) of a “horrid doubt” as to whether the convictions of a mind developed from lower animals are trustworthy. The philosopher Alvin Plantinga developed a similar argument known as the “evolutionary argument against naturalism.”
Note: this argument does not attack the theory of evolution as science (see Does the theory of evolution disprove God?), but questions the belief that nature is the only reality.
3. Reason as God’s image
The Bible says humans were created in God’s image (Genesis 1:27) and that the Word (Logos, which also means reason) is the source of all things (John 1:1–3). God invites: “Come now, and let’s reason together” (Isaiah 1:18). See also Isn’t faith just believing without evidence?
Next step
See the other questions in Stage 1 · Does God really exist?
References
- Bible: Genesis 1:27; Isaiah 1:18; John 1:1–3; Romans 12:2.
- C.S. Lewis, Miracles (1947), chapter 3.
- Charles Darwin, letter to William Graham, July 3, 1881.
- Alvin Plantinga, Where the Conflict Really Lies (Oxford University Press, 2011).
Comments
Post a Comment