Aren’t Atheists Just Disbelieving in One More God?

published · topics: Existence of God, Reason, Stage 1

There is a popular line: “You’re an atheist about Zeus, Thor, and thousands of other gods. I just go one god further.” It sounds clever, but this argument mixes up two very different things.

The gods of mythology are beings within the universe: they are born, have limits, quarrel, and rule particular domains. But God in the Christian faith (and in the classical philosophical tradition) is the source of the existence of everything, not one more “thing” inside nature. Rejecting Zeus is like rejecting the existence of one character in a story; rejecting God means denying that the story has an Author.

So the question is not “how many gods do we reject?” but “does the universe need an explanation outside itself?” That question has to be answered with arguments, not by counting.

Full explanation & Bible references

1. Where the argument comes from

The line was popularized by Stephen F. Roberts and Richard Dawkins. Its strength is rhetorical: it makes faith in God look the same as believing in ancient gods. But rejecting many false claims does not automatically prove that every claim of the same kind is false.

2. God is not a “big god”

The Christian creeds call God the “Maker of heaven and earth, of all things visible and invisible.” He has no beginning (Psalm 90:2), depends on nothing (Acts 17:24–25), and “in him we live, and move, and have our being” (Acts 17:28). The philosopher David Bentley Hart stresses that the difference between God and the gods is not a difference of number, but of kind.

3. The real question

Why is there something rather than nothing? What explains the order of the laws of nature and of the moral law? These are the questions the arguments for God’s existence address. See Does God really exist? and If God created the universe, who created God?

Next step

If God exists, which God? Go on to Stage 2.

References

  • Bible: Psalm 90:2; Isaiah 44:6–20; Acts 17:22–31.
  • David Bentley Hart, The Experience of God (Yale University Press, 2013).
  • Frank Turek, Stealing from God (NavPress, 2014).

Comments