Does the Theory of Evolution Disprove God?

published · topics: Science, Stage 1

People often assume: “If evolution is true, God isn’t needed.” But hold on. Even if the entire theory of biological evolution is true, it only explains how living things change, not where the universe, the laws of nature, and the first life came from.

We need to distinguish between evolution as a scientific theory and evolutionism, the philosophical belief that nature came about with no purpose at all. The second is not a laboratory result but a worldview.

Christians themselves hold several views on how God created: some believe in a young earth, some believe in progressive creation over billions of years, and some Christian scientists accept evolution as the way God worked. They differ on how, but agree on who: God is the Creator (Genesis 1:1).

Full explanation & Bible references

1. What evolution does not explain

  • The origin of the universe. Biological evolution only operates once living things exist. It does not explain why there is a universe (see Does God really exist?).
  • The laws of nature and fine-tuning. Evolution assumes physical and chemical laws that already exist and are orderly.
  • The origin of the first life. Natural selection needs organisms that can reproduce. How the first cell, with its genetic information, came to be is still an open question in science.
  • Reason and consciousness. If our minds are only the product of a blind process aimed at survival, why should we trust our reason to find truth? C.S. Lewis discusses this problem in his book Miracles.

2. Scientific theory vs. worldview

A scientific theory explains a mechanism. The view that “nature came about without purpose and without a Creator” is a philosophical claim. Charles Darwin himself, in later editions of On the Origin of Species, closed the book by speaking of life having been “breathed by the Creator” into a few original forms. Whatever his personal beliefs later became, he did not consider his theory to automatically rule out a Creator.

3. A range of Christian views

  • Young-earth creation: reads the days of Genesis 1 as literal days.
  • Old-earth / progressive creation: accepts an earth billions of years old, with God’s creative acts happening in stages.
  • Theistic evolution / evolutionary creation: God used the process of evolution. This view is held by, among others, Francis Collins.

Churches, including those in the Lutheran tradition, do not all agree on this. What is at the core of the Christian faith is that God is the Creator of all things, that human beings are made in His image, and that humanity fell into sin and needs a Savior.

4. What the Bible says

“In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth” (Genesis 1:1). “By him all things were created… and in him all things are held together” (Colossians 1:16–17). “By faith we understand that the universe has been framed by the word of God” (Hebrews 11:3).

Next step

If nature needs a Creator, where does our sense of right and wrong come from? See the other questions in Stage 1 · Does God really exist?

References

  • Bible: Genesis 1:1, 27; Colossians 1:16–17; Hebrews 11:3.
  • Francis S. Collins, The Language of God (Free Press, 2006).
  • John C. Lennox, Seven Days That Divide the World (Zondervan, 2011).
  • C.S. Lewis, Miracles (1947), chapter 3.
  • Charles Darwin, On the Origin of Species, 2nd edition (1860), closing sentence.

Comments