Listen to everyday arguments: “That’s not fair!”, “You promised!”, “Don’t cut in line!” People who quarrel don’t just say “I don’t like it”; they appeal to a standard they assume applies to everyone. C.S. Lewis begins his book Mere Christianity with this simple observation.
We all know some things are really wrong, not merely disliked: torturing a child for fun, for example. The question is: if the universe is only matter with no purpose, where do “ought” and “must not” come from? Atoms have no moral obligations.
A moral law that applies to everyone points to a Lawgiver above humanity. The Bible says that law is “written in the hearts” of every person (Romans 2:15). And there is the problem: we all know the standard, yet we all break it often.
Full explanation & Bible references
1. The moral law we all know
Lewis calls it “the Law of Human Nature.” Cultures may differ on details (how many wives a man may have, how to honor parents), but no culture praises cowards, people who betray their friends, or those who cheat someone who has been kind to them. If there were no real moral standard, we could not even say that abolishing slavery was progress. It would only be a “change in taste.”
2. The problem of morality without God
Many atheists live very moral lives, and that deserves respect (see Can people be good without God?). The question is not whether atheists can do good, but what the foundation of that goodness is. If humans are only the product of a blind natural process, morality is at most an instinct that helps survival or a social agreement. Instincts and agreements can change. If a majority agrees to oppress a minority, what makes that wrong?
3. The moral argument, briefly
- If God does not exist, objective moral values do not exist.
- Objective moral values do exist (torturing a child for fun is really wrong).
- Therefore, God exists.
Frank Turek calls this “stealing from God”: people use moral standards to put God on trial, when those standards only make sense if God exists.
4. What the Bible says
Even nations that do not have the law “show the work of the law written in their hearts, their conscience testifying with them” (Romans 2:14–15). But the Bible is also honest: “all have sinned, and fall short of the glory of God” (Romans 3:23). The moral law shows there is a Lawgiver, and at the same time shows that we need forgiveness. That is where the good news about Jesus becomes important.
Next step
See the other questions in Stage 1 · Does God really exist? or go straight to Stage 4 · I’m starting to believe. Now what?
References
- Bible: Romans 2:14–15; 3:23.
- C.S. Lewis, Mere Christianity, Book 1, chapters 1–5.
- Frank Turek, Stealing from God (NavPress, 2014), chapter on morality.
- William Lane Craig, Reasonable Faith, 3rd edition (Crossway, 2008), chapter 2.
Comments
Post a Comment