Did Emperor Constantine Decide the Contents of the Bible and the Divinity of Jesus?

published · topics: Bible, Christian Facts vs Myths, Jesus, Stage 3

Myth: Emperor Constantine and the Council of Nicaea (AD 325) chose the books of the Bible and “made” Jesus God by a vote. Fact: the Council of Nicaea did not discuss the list of biblical books at all. Not a single decision of Nicaea defined the canon.

Nicaea dealt with the teaching of Arius, who said the Son of God was a created being. The bishops affirmed that the Son is “of one substance with the Father.” They were not inventing a new teaching, but defending a belief Christians had been writing and singing since the first century.

The four Gospels were already widely recognized about 150 years before Nicaea. Around the year 180, Bishop Irenaeus was already naming exactly four Gospels: Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John.

Full explanation & Bible references

1. What was actually discussed at Nicaea

About 300 bishops gathered at Constantine’s invitation. The main topics: the teaching of Arius, the date of Easter, and some church regulations (disciplinary canons). Ancient records of the council, including from Eusebius, who was there, do not mention any discussion of a list of biblical books. That claim was popularized by fiction such as The Da Vinci Code (2003).

2. The divinity of Jesus before Nicaea

  • John 1:1; 20:28 (“My Lord and my God!”); Philippians 2:6; Colossians 2:9, all written in the first century.
  • Ignatius of Antioch (around AD 110) speaks of “Jesus Christ our God.”
  • The Roman governor Pliny the Younger (around AD 112) reported that Christians sang hymns “to Christ as to a god.”

And the vote at Nicaea wasn’t close: only two bishops refused to sign the creed.

3. How the canon took shape

The New Testament canon took shape gradually as churches used the apostles’ writings in worship. Irenaeus (around 180) defended four Gospels, the Muratorian Fragment (late 2nd century) lists most of the New Testament books, and Athanasius’s Easter letter of 367 lists the 27 New Testament books we know. See What is the biblical canon? and Has the Gospel been changed?

Next step

See the other questions in Stage 3, or read about other myths in the Christian Facts vs Myths category.

References

  • Eusebius, Life of Constantine 3.6–14.
  • Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3.11.8 (c. 180).
  • Pliny the Younger, Letters 10.96.
  • Bart D. Ehrman, Truth and Fiction in The Da Vinci Code (2004).
  • Michael J. Kruger, Canon Revisited (2012).

Comments