What If My Conscience Contradicts the Bible?

published · topics: Bible, Morality, Stage 5

Christianity teaches that God wrote the moral law on the human heart (Romans 2:15). So what if my conscience feels that something is good, while the Bible says otherwise? A common example today is sexuality, including homosexuality.

First, conscience is real but can be mistaken. It gives us clear general principles (for example: torturing children is evil), but how we apply them to particular cases can be shaped, even bent, by culture, desire, and habit.

Second, history shows that majority intuitions are often wrong. Many societies once felt slavery was normal. That is why we need a standard outside our own feelings.

Third, if God exists and has spoken, the honest question is not “what do I feel?” but “is the Bible really from God?” If it is, He knows our design better than our feelings do.

Full explanation & Bible references

1. Conscience: a compass that needs calibrating

Paul recognized that even people without the Law show “the work of the law written in their hearts” (Romans 2:14–15). But he also wrote: “For I know nothing against myself. Yet I am not justified by this” (1 Corinthians 4:4). A quiet conscience is not necessarily a correct one. A conscience can be “seared” until it is numb (1 Timothy 4:2). Jeremiah even says: “The heart is deceitful above all things and it is exceedingly corrupt. Who can know it?” (Jeremiah 17:9).

C.S. Lewis in Mere Christianity distinguishes the moral law itself (which is objective) from our impulses and feelings (which can conflict with each other). The moral law often says “no” to our strongest impulse.

2. Feelings are not the same as actions

Every human being has desires that are better not acted on: anger, envy, greed, lust. The Bible does not blame anyone for experiencing a particular attraction; its call concerns how we act. This applies to everyone, whatever their orientation. The same Christian sexual ethic applies to heterosexual people: sex belongs only within lifelong marriage between a man and a woman (Genesis 2:24; Matthew 19:4–6). See Why does Christianity teach that sex belongs in marriage?

Christians who hold this teaching are still called to love, respect, and befriend everyone. Disagreement is not hatred.

3. The more basic question

If there is no God, how do we know whose intuition is right? See If there is no God, where do right and wrong come from? If God exists and Jesus rose from the dead, then His teaching has authority over our feelings, and He also gives grace, forgiveness, and community to those who struggle.

Next step

See the other questions in Stage 5 · I believe, but I’m confused.

References

  • Bible: Genesis 2:24; Jeremiah 17:9; Matthew 19:4–6; Romans 2:14–15; 1 Corinthians 4:4; 1 Timothy 4:2.
  • C.S. Lewis, Mere Christianity (1952), Book 1.
  • Sam Allberry, Is God Anti-Gay? (The Good Book Company, 2013).
  • J. Budziszewski, What We Can’t Not Know (Spence, 2003).

Comments