The internet is full of claims that Jesus is just a copy of ancient gods like Horus, Mithras, or Dionysus: born of a virgin on December 25, had 12 disciples, died and rose again. It sounds convincing, but when you check the original sources, most of these parallels either don’t exist or are exaggerated.
Even scholars who are not believers reject this theory. Bart Ehrman, an agnostic historian, says many of these claims are not supported by evidence. December 25 isn’t even in the Bible; it is a later church tradition.
Besides, the story of Jesus is rooted in first-century Judaism, not in pagan mythology. His disciples were Jews who strongly rejected foreign gods. And His story is set in real history: under Pontius Pilate, in Jerusalem, with witnesses named by name.
Full explanation & Bible references
1. Checking the claims
- Horus: according to Egyptian myth, Horus was conceived by Isis from the dead Osiris, not by a virgin. There are no ancient Egyptian sources about 12 disciples or a crucifixion.
- Mithras: according to myth, Mithras was born from a rock. Nearly everything we know about the Roman cult of Mithras comes from after the New Testament, so if there was any influence, it may well have gone the other way.
- “Dying and rising” gods: many scholars now doubt this category. Stories like that of Osiris are more like becoming ruler of the underworld than a bodily resurrection in history.
2. What scholars say
In Did Jesus Exist?, Ehrman criticizes claimed parallels with pagan gods because they are often unsourced. Scholars such as T.N.D. Mettinger, who accept a pattern of dying and rising gods, still conclude that the disciples did not understand Jesus’ resurrection as that kind of seasonal myth.
3. Why are there similarities?
C.S. Lewis, an expert in mythology, wrestled with this question. Tolkien helped him see that the story of Christ is “myth become fact”: the human longing for death and new life, expressed in many stories, finally really happened in history. General similarities do not prove copying; many hero stories are similar without borrowing from one another.
Next step
See the other questions in Stage 3, or go on to Stage 4 · I’m starting to believe. Now what?
References
- Bible: Luke 3:1–2; 1 Corinthians 15:3–8; 2 Peter 1:16 (“we did not follow cunningly devised fables”).
- Bart D. Ehrman, Did Jesus Exist? (HarperOne, 2012).
- C.S. Lewis, “Myth Became Fact,” in God in the Dock (1970).
- Mary Jo Sharp, “Does the Story of Jesus Mimic Pagan Mystery Stories?”, in Come Let Us Reason (B&H, 2012).
Comments
Post a Comment