Did Christmas Come From a Sun-God Festival?

published · topics: Christmas Myths, Other Views, Stage 5

Myth: Christmas is a Roman sun-god festival that was “Christianized.” Fact: the historical evidence is much weaker than often claimed. Saturnalia ended on December 23, not the 25th. A festival of the “Birth of the Unconquered Sun” on December 25 is only clearly recorded in the 4th century, at almost the same time as the record of Christmas.

Some historians even argue the reverse: Christians had already calculated December 25 from the belief that Jesus was conceived on March 25, and no ancient Christian writer says they chose that date to replace a pagan festival.

Even if some Christmas customs (such as the Christmas tree) come from local cultures, the meaning of Christmas isn’t determined by where its decorations came from. What is celebrated is the incarnation: God becoming human in Jesus.

Full explanation & Bible references

1. Weighing the Saturnalia and Sol Invictus claims

  • Saturnalia was a Roman festival for the god Saturn, celebrated around December 17–23. Its dates are not the same as Christmas.
  • Sol Invictus: Emperor Aurelian founded a temple to the sun god in 274. But evidence that its festival fell on December 25 before the 4th century is very limited, and some researchers (such as Steven Hijmans) doubt it.
  • The oldest record mentioning both appears in the same document, the Chronograph of 354. That does not prove which borrowed from which.

2. The calculation theory

Early Christian writers such as Tertullian connected the date of Jesus’ death with March 25. There was a belief at the time that holy people died on the same date they were conceived. Nine months after March 25 is December 25. Augustine also told his congregation to celebrate that day not for the sake of the sun, but for the sake of Him who made the sun.

3. How to respond

The church has often used cultural forms to proclaim the gospel (compare Acts 17:22–31). What matters is not the origin of a custom, but whether it is used to glorify Christ. See also Was Jesus really born on December 25? and Is the story of Jesus copied from ancient myths?

Next step

See the other questions in Stage 5.

References

  • Andrew McGowan, “How December 25 Became Christmas,” Biblical Archaeology Society (2002).
  • Steven Hijmans, “Sol Invictus, the Winter Solstice, and the Origins of Christmas,” Mouseion 3 (2003).
  • W. Simmons, “The Origins of Christmas and the Date of Christ’s Birth,” JETS 58/2 (2015).
  • Augustine, Sermon 190 on Christmas.

Comments