Why Did God Allow Adam and Eve to Fall Into Sin?

published · topics: Evil & Suffering, God, Stage 5

It’s a fair question: if God knows everything and can do anything, why didn’t He prevent the fall? The classic Christian answer: God created humans for love, and real love requires freedom. A robot programmed to say “I love you” doesn’t really love.

C.S. Lewis wrote that free will is indeed what makes evil possible, but it is also the only thing that makes possible any love, goodness, or joy worth having. God apparently thought a world of free creatures, even ones who could go wrong, worth more than a world of machines.

And God did not let the fall be the end of the story. Even before the world was made, the plan of redemption in Christ was already there (1 Peter 1:20; Ephesians 1:4). In Genesis 3:15, right after the fall, God already promised an offspring of the woman who would crush the serpent’s head. The fall was real and tragic, but grace is greater (Romans 5:20).

Full explanation & Bible references

1. Love and freedom

God placed humans in a good garden with one prohibition (Genesis 2:16–17). That prohibition made room for genuine obedience: trusting that God is good. The fall happened when humans doubted God’s goodness and wanted to be like God without God (Genesis 3:1–6).

A note: the Lutheran tradition distinguishes the freedom Adam and Eve had before the fall from the human condition afterward. We still make real choices in everyday life, but in spiritual matters we can no longer choose God by our own strength; faith is His gift. See If God knows everything, do humans still have free will?

2. Lewis’s view

In Mere Christianity (Book 2, chapter 3), Lewis writes that God created creatures with free will because the happiness He intends for them is the happiness of being freely and voluntarily united to Him. In The Problem of Pain, he adds that an orderly world with fixed laws (which makes real choice possible) also makes its misuse possible.

3. The plan of redemption

The church’s ancient Easter Vigil hymn (the Exsultet) even dares to call Adam’s sin a “happy fault” because it brought so great a Redeemer. This does not excuse sin; it marvels at how God can turn the very worst into glory for Himself and good for us (Romans 5:12–21; 8:28).

4. The limits of our understanding

There is a mystery here that is not fully answered (Deuteronomy 29:29). But from the cross we know this: God does not stand at a distance from the consequences of sin; He entered into them and bore them Himself. See also Why does God allow suffering?

Next step

See the other questions in Stage 5.

References

  • Bible: Genesis 2:15–17; 3:1–15; Deuteronomy 29:29; Romans 5:12–21; 8:28; Ephesians 1:4; 1 Peter 1:20.
  • C.S. Lewis, Mere Christianity, Book 2, chapter 3; The Problem of Pain, chapters 2 and 5.
  • Alvin Plantinga, God, Freedom, and Evil (Eerdmans, 1974).

Comments