Isn’t It Arrogant and Intolerant to Claim One Religion Is True?

published · topics: Other Views, Stage 2

In a diverse society, the statement “Jesus is the only way” can sound arrogant. It is a fair question. But we need to distinguish between tolerance and relativism. Tolerance means respecting people who hold different beliefs, not pretending every belief is equally true.

In fact, every view makes exclusive claims, including the view that “all religions are the same.” That view also says anyone who believes in one way is wrong. So the question is not who makes exclusive claims, but which claim is true and how we share it.

The Christian claim does not come from feeling superior. Christians actually admit they cannot save themselves. A Sri Lankan pastor, D.T. Niles, put it this way: evangelism is just one beggar telling another beggar where to find bread.

Full explanation & Bible references

1. True tolerance

Tolerance is only possible when we actually disagree. We don’t “tolerate” people who agree with us. True tolerance means: I believe my convictions are true, you believe yours are true, and we still respect each other, speak courteously, and live side by side. That is the heart of living peacefully in a pluralistic society.

2. Everyone makes exclusive claims

Atheists believe all religions are wrong. Pluralists believe the exclusive claims of the religions are wrong. The major religions each believe their own teaching is true. There is no truly neutral position. What makes the difference is the reasons behind a view and the way it is shared.

3. A claim born of grace

Christians do not say, “We are more pious, so we are right.” We say that all people, ourselves included, are sinners who need grace (Romans 3:23–24; Ephesians 2:8–9). The exclusive claim does not belong to Christians; it comes from Jesus Himself (John 14:6; Acts 4:12). If He is right, hiding it would actually be unloving.

4. How to share it

Peter writes that we should be ready to give an answer “with humility and fear” (1 Peter 3:15–16). Paul spoke in Athens by respecting his listeners’ spiritual longing before introducing Jesus (Acts 17:22–31). Truth without love loses its voice; love without truth loses its substance (Ephesians 4:15).

Next step

See the other questions in Stage 2, or learn how to talk about faith respectfully in Stage 7 · How do I share my faith?

References

  • Bible: John 14:6; Acts 4:12; 17:22–31; Romans 3:23–24; Ephesians 2:8–9; 4:15; 1 Peter 3:15–16.
  • Timothy Keller, The Reason for God (Dutton, 2008), chapter 1.
  • D.T. Niles, That They May Have Life (Harper, 1951).

Comments