Is the Order of the Universe Just Chance?

published · topics: Existence of God, Science, Stage 1

Imagine walking into a hotel room and finding the temperature just right, your favorite song playing, and your favorite food already served. Would you say, “Wow, what a coincidence”? Of course not. You would think: someone prepared this for me.

That is what physicists have found about the universe. A number of basic values in the laws of physics, such as the strength of gravity and the cosmological constant, fall within extremely narrow ranges. If they shifted even slightly, there would be no stars, no planets, and no life.

There are only three possible explanations: physical necessity, chance, or design. The first two have big problems. Even the astronomer Fred Hoyle, who was not a Christian, concluded that it looks as though a “superintellect” has monkeyed with physics.

The Bible says: “The heavens declare the glory of God” (Psalm 19:1). The deeper science digs, the clearer the Designer’s fingerprints become.

Full explanation & Bible references

1. What is “fine-tuning”?

Physicists call it fine-tuning. Some commonly discussed examples:

  • The cosmological constant (dark energy). Physicists, including Nobel laureate Steven Weinberg, have noted that its value must lie in an incredibly narrow range compared with what theory says it “should” be. If it were slightly larger, the universe would expand too fast for galaxies to form.
  • The strong nuclear force. If it were slightly weaker or stronger, the elements life needs, such as carbon, would not form in sufficient amounts.
  • The ratio of gravity to electromagnetism. If it were slightly different, stars would burn out too quickly or never ignite.

Britain’s Astronomer Royal, Martin Rees, wrote a book called Just Six Numbers about six such values. Rees himself is not religious, but he acknowledges the fact of fine-tuning.

2. Three possible explanations

  • Necessity: could the values simply have to be what they are? No physical theory shows that they must take their current values. Mathematically, other values are possible.
  • Chance: the odds are too small. One coincidence can be shrugged off; layer upon layer of coincidence across many values at once demands an explanation.
  • Design: a Mind deliberately set up the universe so that life would be possible.

3. What about the multiverse?

Some scientists propose that there are trillions of other universes, so it is no surprise that one of them suits life. But so far the multiverse cannot be observed or tested. Besides, any “machine” that produces many universes would itself need fine-tuning, so the question is only moved back, not answered.

4. What the Bible says

“The heavens declare the glory of God. The expanse shows his handiwork” (Psalm 19:1). God “formed the earth… he didn’t create it a waste, he formed it to be inhabited” (Isaiah 45:18). He appointed “the ordinances of heaven and earth” (Jeremiah 33:25).

Next step

If the universe was designed, does science contradict faith? See the other questions in Stage 1 · Does God really exist?

References

  • Bible: Psalm 19:1; Isaiah 45:18; Jeremiah 33:25.
  • Martin Rees, Just Six Numbers (Basic Books, 1999).
  • Fred Hoyle, “The Universe: Past and Present Reflections,” Engineering & Science (November 1981).
  • Norman Geisler & Frank Turek, I Don't Have Enough Faith to Be an Atheist (Crossway, 2004), chapter 4.
  • Luke A. Barnes & Geraint F. Lewis, A Fortunate Universe (Cambridge University Press, 2016).

Comments