Sigmund Freud argued that God is just a projection of the human wish for a protective father figure. We fear death and loneliness, so we invent God to comfort ourselves.
The trouble is, this argument proves nothing. Wanting something does not make it false. Thirsty people want water, and water really exists. Besides, the argument can be turned around: perhaps atheism too is born from a wish not to be held accountable by God.
And if humans invented God for comfort, why is the God of the Bible so often uncomfortable? He is holy, demanding, exposes our sin, and asks us to deny ourselves. C.S. Lewis, once an atheist, said he came to God reluctantly, “kicking, struggling.”
Full explanation & Bible references
1. Freud’s argument
In The Future of an Illusion (1927), Freud called religion an illusion born of the human wish for protection. He did not prove that God does not exist; he assumed God does not exist and then tried to explain why people still believe.
2. Why this argument is weak
- The genetic fallacy. Explaining why someone believes something does not decide whether it is true. A child believes the earth is round because her parents told her; the earth is still round.
- It can be reversed. The atheist philosopher Thomas Nagel wrote candidly in The Last Word (1997) that he wants atheism to be true and hopes there is no God. Wishes can push in both directions.
- Desire points to reality. C.S. Lewis argued the opposite: deep longing usually points to something real (see What is the meaning of life if God doesn’t exist?).
3. A God we would never have invented
If humans invented a God to suit their taste, we would probably make one who always agrees with us. The God of the Bible is different: He demands holiness (Leviticus 19:2), condemns injustice, and calls us to love our enemies (Matthew 5:44). Jesus said that whoever wants to follow Him must deny himself and take up his cross (Mark 8:34).
Lewis describes his conversion in 1929 in Surprised by Joy: he knelt and admitted that God was God, as “the most dejected and reluctant convert in all England.” That is not the picture of someone looking for comfort.
4. What the Bible says
Paul says God made people “that they should seek the Lord, if perhaps they might reach out for him and find him, though he is not far from each one of us” (Acts 17:27). He also writes that what can be known about God “is revealed in them,” but people tend to suppress it (Romans 1:18–21).
Next step
If God is real, which God? Go on to Stage 2 · If so, which God?
References
- Bible: Leviticus 19:2; Matthew 5:44; Mark 8:34; Acts 17:27; Romans 1:18–21.
- Sigmund Freud, The Future of an Illusion (1927).
- Thomas Nagel, The Last Word (Oxford University Press, 1997), p. 130.
- C.S. Lewis, Surprised by Joy (1955), chapter 14.
- Armand M. Nicholi Jr., The Question of God: C.S. Lewis and Sigmund Freud Debate God, Love, Sex, and the Meaning of Life (Free Press, 2002).
Comments
Post a Comment