Aren’t Miracles Impossible?

published · topics: Faith, Reason, Stage 2

Many people reject Christianity because of miracles: people rising from the dead, water turning into wine. “That breaks the laws of nature!” But C.S. Lewis pointed out that the laws of nature describe what happens if nothing interferes; they do not forbid interference.

The real question is not “are miracles possible?” but “does God exist?” If God exists, the One who made the laws of nature can certainly act within them. Frank Turek often says: if Genesis 1:1 is true and God created the universe out of nothing, then the other miracles in the Bible are no great difficulty.

Believing in miracles does not mean believing anything. Miracle claims still have to be tested against evidence, such as eyewitnesses and historical sources. The greatest miracle in the Christian faith, the resurrection of Jesus, is one that can be examined historically.

Full explanation & Bible references

1. The laws of nature do not forbid

In Miracles (chapter 8), Lewis gives an example: if I put six coins in a drawer on Monday and six more on Tuesday, the laws of arithmetic say there will be twelve on Wednesday, provided no one takes any. If a thief takes some, the laws of arithmetic have not been broken. The laws of nature describe patterns; they do not force the Creator never to act.

2. The underlying question

David Hume rejected miracles because they go against common experience. But if we start by assuming miracles are impossible, we never really examine the evidence; we just reject it before looking. If there is a Creator (see Stage 1), miracles are not impossible; the only question is whether He chose to act.

3. Miracles are still tested

The Bible does not ask us to believe every miracle claim. Biblical miracles usually happened in public, had a purpose (confirming God’s message), and were recorded by witnesses (John 20:30–31; Acts 2:22). Paul mentions hundreds of witnesses to the resurrection who were still alive and could be questioned (1 Corinthians 15:6).

4. The greatest miracle

“In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth” (Genesis 1:1). Creation out of nothing is the greatest miracle. The resurrection of Jesus is the miracle on which the Christian faith rests. See the evidence in Stage 3 · Who is Jesus, really?

Next step

Go on to Stage 3 · Who is Jesus, really?

References

  • Bible: Genesis 1:1; John 20:30–31; Acts 2:22; 1 Corinthians 15:6.
  • C.S. Lewis, Miracles (1947), chapter 8.
  • Norman Geisler & Frank Turek, I Don't Have Enough Faith to Be an Atheist (Crossway, 2004), chapter 8.
  • David Hume, An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding (1748), section 10.

Comments